SourceSecurity.com
  • Products
    CCTV
    • CCTV cameras
    • CCTV software
    • IP cameras
    • Digital video recorders (DVRs)
    • Dome cameras
    • Network video recorders (NVRs)
    • IP Dome cameras
    • CCTV camera lenses
    Access Control
    • Access control readers
    • Access control software
    • Access control controllers
    • Access control systems & kits
    • Audio, video or keypad entry
    • Electronic locking devices
    • Access control cards/ tags/ fobs
    • Access control system accessories
    Intruder Alarms
    • Intruder alarm system control panels & accessories
    • Intruder detectors
    • Intruder warning devices
    • Intruder alarm communicators
    • Intruder alarm accessories
    • Intruder alarm lighting systems
    Topics
    • Artificial intelligence (AI)
    • Counter Terror
    • Cyber security
    • Robotics
    • Thermal imaging
    • Intrusion detection
    Hikvision 4G solar kit for remote security

    Hikvision 4G solar kit for remote security

    Climax unveils Hybrid Security System

    Climax unveils Hybrid Security System

    Dahua Panoramic PTZ WizMind Network Camera

    Dahua Panoramic PTZ WizMind Network Camera

  • Companies
    Companies
    • Manufacturers
    • Distributors
    • Resellers / Dealers / Reps
    • Installers
    • Consultants
    • Systems integrators
    • Events / Training / Services
    • Manned guarding
    Companies by Product area
    • CCTV
    • Access control
    • Intruder alarm
    • IP networking products
    • Biometrics
    • Software
    • Digital video recording
    • Intercom systems
    Topics
    • Artificial intelligence (AI)
    • Counter Terror
    • Cyber security
    • Robotics
    • Thermal imaging
    • Intrusion detection
  • News
    News
    • Product news
    • Corporate news
    • Case studies
    • Events news
    Latest
    • SALTO highlights the importance of cybersecurity to safeguard touchless access control devices
    • Zicam Integrated Security announces the appointment of David Salisbury as Managing Director
    • OfficerReports launches OfficerBilling software for security guard companies to handle competitive billing rates
    • Assured Data Protection partners with Confluera to deliver comprehensive cloud data management solution
    Topics
    • Artificial intelligence (AI)
    • Counter Terror
    • Cyber security
    • Robotics
    • Thermal imaging
    • Intrusion detection
  • Insights
    Insights
    • Expert commentary
    • Security beat
    • Round table discussions
    • Security bytes
    • Round Table Expert Panel
    Featured
    • Expert roundup: healthy buildings, blockchain, AI, skilled workers, and more
    • Smart Offices: How is mobile ID changing the way we access the office?
    • Water plant attack emphasizes cyber’s impact on physical security
    • Remote Monitoring technology: Tackling South Africa’s cable theft problem
    Topics
    • Artificial intelligence (AI)
    • Counter Terror
    • Cyber security
    • Robotics
    • Thermal imaging
    • Intrusion detection
  • Markets
    Markets
    • Airports & Ports
    • Banking & Finance
    • Education
    • Hotels, Leisure & Entertainment
    • Government & Public Services
    • Healthcare
    • Remote Monitoring
    • Retail
    • Transportation
    • Industrial & Commercial
    Topics
    • Artificial intelligence (AI)
    • Counter Terror
    • Cyber security
    • Robotics
    • Thermal imaging
    • Intrusion detection
    Dahua Technology installs HD CCTV cameras with smart analytics using AI to secure iconic Battle of Britain Bunker

    Dahua Technology installs HD CCTV cameras with smart analytics using AI to secure iconic Battle of Britain Bunker

    Oliver Law Security installs Vanderbilt ACT365 security system to protect one of Doncaster’s largest gyms, The Fitness Village

    Oliver Law Security installs Vanderbilt ACT365 security system to protect one of Doncaster’s largest gyms, The Fitness Village

    Hikvision IP CCTV systems protect visitors and stores at Somerset Mall in South Africa

    Hikvision IP CCTV systems protect visitors and stores at Somerset Mall in South Africa

    CLIQ® access control solution from ASSA ABLOY helps secure museums, shopping and indoor leisure sites

    CLIQ® access control solution from ASSA ABLOY helps secure museums, shopping and indoor leisure sites

  • Virtual events
    Virtual events
    • Video Surveillance
    • Access Control
    • Video Analytics
    • Video Management Systems
    • Integrated Systems
    • Asset Management
    Events
    • International security
    • Regional security
    • Vertical market
    • Technology areas
    • Conferences / seminars
    • Company sponsored
    Topics
    • Artificial intelligence (AI)
    • Counter Terror
    • Cyber security
    • Robotics
    • Thermal imaging
    • Intrusion detection
    Shifting trends in operation centers and control rooms for 2021

    Shifting trends in operation centers and control rooms for 2021

    Capture new opportunities with computer vision and video analytics

    Capture new opportunities with computer vision and video analytics

    How Open Supervised Device Protocol (OSDP) is revolutionising access control systems

    How Open Supervised Device Protocol (OSDP) is revolutionising access control systems

    The World of Access Control Webinar - Part 2

    The World of Access Control Webinar - Part 2

  • White papers
    White papers
    • Video Surveillance
    • Access Control
    • Video Analytics
    • Video Compression
    • Security Storage
    White papers by company
    • HID Global
    • Nedap Security Management
    • Security & Safety Things
    • Hanwha Techwin America
    • ASSA ABLOY
    Other Resources
    • eMagazines
    • Videos
    Topics
    • Artificial intelligence (AI)
    • Counter Terror
    • Cyber security
    • Robotics
    • Thermal imaging
    • Intrusion detection
    Solve access control challenges in the healthcare sector

    Solve access control challenges in the healthcare sector

    The role of access control in a safe return to the workplace

    The role of access control in a safe return to the workplace

    10 step guide to staying ahead of emerging security threats

    10 step guide to staying ahead of emerging security threats

    2021 Trends in Video Surveillance

    2021 Trends in Video Surveillance

About us Advertise
  • Artificial intelligence (AI)
  • Counter Terror
  • Cyber security
  • Robotics
  • Thermal imaging
  • Intrusion detection
  • Body worn video cameras
  • ISC West
  • Video management software
  • Video analytics
  • COVID-19
  • View all
Thermal imaging
  • Home
  • About
  • News
  • Expert commentary
  • Security beat
  • Case studies
  • Round table
  • Products
  • White papers
  • Videos
Thermal imaging

Debunking the myths of EBT Cameras in a COVID-19 world

Debunking the myths of EBT Cameras in a COVID-19 world
Eran Bluestein
Eran Bluestein
Download PDF version
Share with LinkedIn Share with Twitter Share with Facebook Share with Facebook
Related Links
  • What are the mainstream uses for thermal cameras?
  • Thermal cameras and smart cities: Preventing COVID-19 in public places
  • What do you need to know about thermal imaging cameras?

The new buzz in the thermal imaging world goes by many names. In a short time, a small niche in the world of IR, which was previously sidelined to make way for more lucrative markets such as security and defence, has taken the top spot in the attention, production and sales for many manufacturers and integrators. 

It’s no surprise considering the size of this new market. Suddenly, hotels, cinemas, malls, hospitals, critical services, public transportation, office buildings and more have become consumers of thermal imaging cameras. Along with that, the more traditional markets, such as security, defense and industry are suffering from budget cuts, project cancellations, or postponements. Combine two of these elements, and the new elevated body temperature (EBT) camera market is easily 3-4 times the size of the other markets combined.

Thermal imaging cameras and common misconceptions

  • Can thermal cameras detect viruses? 

The answer is NO. The best the camera can do is tell you if someone has a higher skin temperature than others. There are many reasons for an elevated body temperature which are not all health-related, such as exercise or even sitting in a warm environment without air-conditioning.

  • Are the cameras accurate?

The accuracy debate is a significant and controversial discussion with much misinformation running around. When discussing accuracy, there are two considerations:

The first consideration is the accuracy of the camera itself versus a blackbody. Blackbodies are devices which can regulate temperature very accurately (although not all are equal) and have a high emissivity level, which means they are almost not affected by surrounding heat or energy. All thermal cameras are calibrated against blackbodies. Still, some manufacturers have been using them in their EBT solutions to give the camera a consistent temperature reference to which it can adjust. The accuracy of the camera in this discussion talks about the camera itself. How sensitive the detector is, internal reflections, lens aperture, noise level and the calibration process itself. Also, if you read the fine print, most manufacturers quote accuracy levels which are valid only in a controlled or laboratory environment. As in, a room with a steady 25°C and a slow shift in temperature (not more than 1°C per hour). Most field conditions don’t allow this – so this low level of accuracy is challenging to replicate in practice.Blackbodies are devices which can regulate temperature very accurately

The other focuses on the fact we are not looking for COVID in black bodies. We are looking for it in humans. And, the substance known as human skin acts very differently. To date, there are no medical models which can predict how skin will behave in different scenarios. We don’t know what the external skin temperature of a man weighing X who was exposed for X minutes to direct or indirect sunlight would be. So, while the black body may be spot on – it has no bearing on the temperature reading of humans. 

So, while we can improve the first issue, the second one is more complicated. One way to circumvent it is by using population statistical analysis and looking for the gradient between the healthy population (which does have existing medical models) to the people with a higher temperature which are statistical anomalies for such a camera.

Thermal cameras and their suitability 

  • Are all thermal cameras suitable for temperature readings?

There is a difference between a thermal camera and a thermometric camera. A thermal camera developed for security and defence are used to detect threats and give situational awareness. We don’t care that two trees with different temperatures will have different colors – we care about the person standing between them. We manipulate the image, so the viewer has a better understanding of what he sees.

With thermometric measurement (as in – thermal temperature reading) we do the exact opposite. We want accurate temperatures readings for each pixel in our screen. A thermometric camera will go through a rigorous calibration together with the lens, which often takes longer. We need to offset, in the calibration tables, minute pixel-sized blemishes in the detector and lens. Those blemishes would be invisible in a thermal image – but can skew the temperature reading and produce inaccurate results. We regularly see suppliers who are using regular thermal cameras with blackbodies to auto adjust the temperature reading as described above. But, if you take that same blackbody and move it a meter to one side, you may discover the camera suddenly registers a different temperature – as not all pixels have a uniform calibration.

  • Does it matter where we scan in humans?

Yes and no. The inner canthus of the eye (the tear duct) is the most relevant external point with the best correlation to internal temperature. People looking at the inner canthus will manage to avoid a lot of the effects of ambient temperature on the skin. The tradeoff is that the inner canthus is a tiny area, and people would need to remove their glasses.

Most of the world’s health organisations consider the difference between a healthy and sick individual to be 1.5° C (or 2.7° F). That change is consistent whether you’re looking at the tear duct, the forehead or a mouth. Thus, the solutions that look at the gradient temperature (population-based solutions) are just as effective when measuring the ambient temperature on the skin of the population tested. 

  • Do people need to stop in front of the camera?

Not necessarily. It depends on the speed of the camera and the temperature detection algorithm. Some cameras can detect people walking very quickly as they only need a few frames to detect the temperature.

  • Will the camera work outdoors?

Most outdoor cameras will suffer from false alarms and misses. Some cameras have very advanced compensation algorithms for this, but they can’t take into account all the dynamic temperature changes, humidity, sporadic energy readings and the “bane of thermal imaging” - turbulence. Therefore, the conditions can strain even the most advanced algorithm. 

Why invest in this technology?

The WHO states, that while asymptomatic transmission exists, it’s much less contagious then symptomatic transmission. Some doctors claim that a person with a fever sheds the virus five times more aggressively than a person with no fever. 

There are clear regulations for businesses to screen individuals for fever

In some countries, there are clear regulations for businesses to screen individuals for fever as they come into the establishment. While you can have a person in the entrance with a contactless thermometer, they must stop people for a 5-second check each time they come in. That would cause long lines in many places with high traffic. And, during testing, standing less than 2 meters from the individual would throw social distancing out the window. If the tester got sick, the next day they would start endangering everyone else they checked.

It’s better to screen automatically and only use the IR thermometer in cases where an alert was triggered and needed to be verified.

Various forms of technology 

We’ve also seen much use of the IR tablets recently. While they are low cost, a person usually needs to stand very close (less than 1 meter) from the monitor to be caught by the camera. Thus, spreading his germs on the glass or plastic cover of the tablet while being screened. 

In conclusion – Thermal EBT cameras are important. They aren’t a miracle cure, and they won’t stop the spread of the virus. And one should be careful of false promises. But along with other solutions (most importantly – masks), they can help protect us during these times and allow the wounded global economy to rejuvenate itself.

Share with LinkedIn Share with Twitter Share with Facebook Share with Facebook
Download PDF version Download PDF version
  • Digital video surveillance
  • Business security systems
  • Physical security
  • Commercial security system
  • Thermal imaging
  • IR cameras
  • COVID-19
  • Related links
  • Articles by Eran Bluestein
Featured white papers
Building a safe ecosystem for visitors post COVID-19

Building a safe ecosystem for visitors post COVID-19

Download
Thermal cameras: Can they accurately detect body temperatures?

Thermal cameras: Can they accurately detect body temperatures?

Download
How to catch shoplifters with thermal imaging

How to catch shoplifters with thermal imaging

Download
Related articles
Thermal cameras and smart cities: Preventing COVID-19 in public places

Thermal cameras and smart cities: Preventing COVID-19 in public places

Elevated temperature screening is paving the way to Britain’s reopening

Elevated temperature screening is paving the way to Britain’s reopening

What are some unusual applications of surveillance cameras you have seen recently?

What are some unusual applications of surveillance cameras you have seen recently?

Follow us

Sections CCTV Access Control Intruder Alarms Companies News Insights Case studies Markets Virtual events Events White papers Videos August 2020 news RSS
Topics Artificial intelligence (AI) Counter Terror Cyber security Robotics Thermal imaging Intrusion detection Body worn video cameras ISC West Video management software
About us Advertise About us 10 guiding principles of editorial content FAQs eNewsletters Sitemap Terms & conditions Privacy policy and cookie policy
See this on SecurityInformed.com

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Stay updated with the latest trends and technologies in the security industry
Sign Up

DMA

SourceSecurity.com - Making the world a safer place
Copyright © Notting Hill Media Limited 2000 - 2021, all rights reserved

Our other sites:
SecurityInformed.com | TheBigRedGuide.com | HVACInformed.com

Subscribe to our Newsletter


SourceSecurity.com
SecurityInformed.com

Browsing from the Americas? Looking for our US Edition?

View this content on SecurityInformed.com, our dedicated portal for our Americas audience.

US Edition International Edition
Sign up now for full access to SourceSecurity.com content
Download Datasheet
Download SourceSecurity.com product tech spec