Download PDF version Contact company
 Advantages of hi-resolution IP cameras
Outdated technology dominating public sector CCTV systems

Why does a common cell phone store images in better resolution than most public sector CCTV systems? Mobotix, manufacturer of hi-resolution IP cameras presents the case for use of new technology in video surveillance installations.

Even basic digital cameras provide more definition than the images from CCTV camera systems that are commonly used to identify terrorists. During the 2006 FIFA World Cup almost all the stadiums were protected by outdated video surveillance cameras. Kaiserslautern alone decided to use some of the most advanced, high-resolution digital surveillance systems now available. A simple comparison between the technology used in both systems clearly highlights the difference in image detail: the simplest of digital cameras stores images of around 3 million pixels (3 Mega pixel); in comparison the "classic" video technology is restricted to 1/30 the pixels (101,000 pixels or 0.1 Mega pixel).  Even the most inexperienced amateur photographer would not buy such a low resolution camera these days. Despite these facts this kind of security camera system is still being specified and deployed in up to 95% of public safety applications.
Systems of choice continues to be old technology blocking uptake of new technology for hi-res IP camers
Slow uptake of new CCTV technology in public sector


50 year old standard blocks innovative technology

The poor quality of the images used in these public safety applications is not, as one would imagine, a result of the currently available technology, but rather the systems specified as the systems of choice. These, in turn, are based on television technology more than 50 years old, using video cameras that deliver live images with a maximum of 0.4 Mega pixels. Due to technical and cost constraints of theses systems, the images are further reduced by a factor of 4:1 to just 0.1 Mega pixels, making facial recognition almost impossible.

Issues with image storage in 0.4 mega pixels

So why do we not store the original image in 0.4 mega pixels? There are video systems that can store images at 0.4 mega pixels, however, these are expensive and do not give the user sufficiently more detail. TV technology standard - the video stream is broadcast in "half frames", and as the name suggests these have only half the detail. The electronic fitting together, or interlacing, of these half frames when viewing or recording moving objects, which is the most important aspect of security surveillance, causes combing distortion (blurred edges) in the image.

Calculating 0.1 megapixel for a CIF image

The image delivered by a video camera has 576 lines made up of 2 half frames, each with 288 lines, which are, exposed consecutively one after the other and then transmitted. Because of the technical and financial considerations mentioned earlier, 95% of systems in use today are digitising and storing on a half frame basis. In context with the width to height ratio, 352 horizontal pixels are digitized for each of the 288 lines resulting in a so-called CIF image with 352 x 288 = 101,000 pixels, which is equivalent to 0.1 Mega pixel.

No improvement through use of 2CIF or 4CIF

The 2CIF image format also uses only 288 lines but combines them with double the amount of pixels per line

View larger image

 Image delivered by a video camera is made up of two half frames

The 2CIF image format also uses only 288 lines but combines them with double the amount of pixels per line, giving us around 0.2 Mega pixel. Despite the increase in pixels per line, a considerable amount of important information is still missing from the image because every second line within each image is simply ignored, leaving us with what is accurately described as a half frame or half image.

Made up of two interlaced consecutive half images, a 4CIF format has indeed 704 x 576 = 0.4 Mega pixel but every second line is staggered or deferred because the half frames are exposed at different times. As a result of this so-called combing effect, 4CIF recording is hardly ever used in actual systems. For example, at the World Cup stadiums only CIF, or in some cases 2CIF, half frames were recorded.

Snapshots are unreliable in facial recognition

An additional problem with existing video technology lies in the low refresh rate of recorded images during playback. Again, because of technical and cost factors, 95% of existing systems cannot achieve more than 1-3 frames per second. With such a low refresh rate of "snapshots", it becomes very difficult to find an image with enough detail for facial recognition.

This low playback rate is the result of one single computer having to digitise and store video feed from multiple cameras. The computing power for full video is generally only sufficient for two cameras, therefore, when recording more cameras the frame rate has to be drastically reduced.

Because of the technical and financial considerations, 95% of security camera systems in use today are digitising and storing on a half frame basis

Because of this limited processing power, MPEG4 also cannot be implemented for the recording of high-resolution video. The processing power is just not available for multiple cameras.

Limiting use of higher resolution video cameras

Why don't the traditional surveillance camera manufacturers simply use high-resolution sensors in their video cameras? The clear, but far from comforting answer is that the standard the systems are based on for the transmission and recording of images is 50 years old and it is technically impossible for the video cable to process such high-resolution images. Understandably the video surveillance industry is reluctant to change; however, to protect the public, change is inevitable.

The digital difference: IP cameras

Mega pixel imaging shows 12 times more detailed resolution

View larger image

MxPEG requires around only 2 Mbps for a high-resolution video stream

New digital technologies also present opportunities for innovative manufacturers to offer new solutions. In the last six years there has been an emphasis on developing Mega pixel technology and transmitting video streams via modern computer networks, LAN, WAN, WLAN or over the Internet. In order to achieve this, a high performance processor with extensive software package for processing, compressing, recording and storage of the image sequences was developed and integrated into the video camera itself.

The extensive research and development undertaken is now showing tangible results. A convincing argument is detailed in the above images which show an enlarged number plate from a stored 1.3 Mega pixel camera, using 960 lines compared to a 0.1 Mega pixel image using 288 lines.

Remote access during recording

One of the great advantages of modern network camera technology is the ability to manage all configurations and to access live and stored images simultaneously while the camera is recording, remotely over the network, anytime, from anywhere in the world. These camera installations will be linked on the existing company network or even the Internet via a secured connection (VPN) and firewall.

In this way, any incident or suspicious behaviour in a train station, airport or any other public place can be immediately investigated by retrieving the images to the control centre via the network without the necessity of having someone on site or having to stop the recording and live viewing. New or improved software for further functionality can simply be loaded into the camera through the network.

Cost advantages of network/ IP video technology

One great advantage of modern network camera technology is the ability to manage all configurations and to access live and stored images simultaneously 

By using 960 instead of conventional 288 lines, a stored image from a camera has 12 times more detail which means, for example when watching turnstiles in a sports stadium, less cameras in total are needed to view the same amount of turnstiles. With a standard 90-degree lens it is now possible to view an entire room in more detail using only one camera.

The use of worldwide IT standards makes it possible to integrate inexpensive system components: whether over copper, glass or wireless via WLAN. A power outlet is not necessary as cameras do not require heating to prevent misting and as a result can be supplied with power via the network cable all year round. That is why the 77 security cameras installed in the World Cup stadium in Kaiserslautern have full functionality with only 500-Watts emergency power. An innovative storage technique developed requires considerably less storage PCs for high resolution and streaming video. Internal buffering of the video within the camera protects the recorded images against power failures of a few minutes duration. The automatic regulation of frame rate based on motion detection further increases the storage capacity of the system.

A direct comparison highlights the difference

A comparison of a CIF image with 288 lines and a camera image with 960 lines dramatically highlights the difference in quality and detail. Mega pixel imaging shows 12 times more detailed resolution, so that a face taking up only 1/40th of the image width is still clearly recognisable. With the appropriate post editing the image quality can be further improved. In comparison, the image extracted from the CIF image is unrecognizable and therefore unusable.

Digital is not always true digital

The majority of IP cameras, or network cameras are still using the old analogue technology internally and merely transmit a digitised image via a computer network. Although it is hard to believe, most IP camera systems are only storing CIF half frames!

40 fluid video streams on one PC

Mega pixel imaging shows 12 times more detailed resolution
Comparison of a CIF with 288 lines and a camera image with 960 lines highlights dramatic difference in quality

The decentralised recording process through the camera itself, enabling the simultaneous recording of around 40 fluid high-resolution video streams on one single PC, which is the equivalent of 4,800 CIF-images per second in the old technology. The commonly used centralised concept cannot, because of the limited PC processing power available, record multiple network cameras in high resolution and have a maximum performance level of 100-200 CIF images per second in total for all cameras.

Switching from the MPEG4 to MxPEG for security video

The video standard MPEG4 was developed for compressing a single video stream (e.g. movie) and not for the compression, management and viewing of multiple high-resolution cameras. MPEG4 transmits moving objects at lower resolution and quality because the human eye does not take in all the detail of a moving object; therefore, it makes no difference when watching a movie. For this very reason MPEG4 is not suitable for security systems because in a security situation, it is these moving objects that are of great importance and must be therefore highly detailed.

To handle the needs of security video, the video standard MxPEG, requiring around only 2 Mbps for a high-resolution video stream and exhibiting a shorter reaction time than MPEG4 is ideal. The MxPEG standard is currently being implemented and supported by manufacturers and developers worldwide.

 

Mobotix AGMobotix AG

Share with LinkedIn Share with Twitter Share with Facebook Share with What's App Share with Facebook
Download PDF version Download PDF version

In case you missed it

ASSA ABLOY Opening Solutions embraces BIM to smooth specification and installation of door security solutions
ASSA ABLOY Opening Solutions embraces BIM to smooth specification and installation of door security solutions

BIM (building information modeling) provides a process for creating and managing information during the building lifecycle and beyond. BIM is often equated with 3D modeling of construction projects, but the visual component is just part of the value of BIM. Additional data, such as specifications and other documentation, is also part of the process, underlying the visual aspects, helping to drive decision making and providing immediate access to detailed information about all facets of the building process. Incorporating BIM systems For the last six years, ASSA ABLOY Opening Solutions has worked with specification writers and architects in Europe, the Middle East, and Africa (EMEA) to make it easy to incorporate ASSA ABLOY Opening Solutions doors, hardware, and security solutions into BIM systems. Everyone on a project can work together in the interactive and information-rich BIM environment. BIM tools are also used by contractors, distributors, facility owners, and security consultants. BIM software BIM information relating to doors, hardware, and security solutions is available in the cloud  BIM information relating to doors, hardware, and security solutions is available in the cloud with the company’s Openings Studio BIM software. This improves the process of door scheduling and visualisation and enables customers to focus on the design, installation, and management of openings. “If you have up-to-date information inside the BIM model, you can reduce mistakes and misunderstanding in the building industry,” says Marc Ameryckx, ASSA ABLOY Opening Solutions’ BIM Manager for the EMEIA region. “It helps to eliminate mistakes before they happen or as early as possible in the building process. The earlier, the less it costs. We provide data as soon as possible in the process.” (ASSA ABLOY Opening Solutions also has comparable systems available in other regions of the global company.) Centralised data in BIM 3D model Expanding the data available in BIM provides additional value compared to merely providing “BIM objects” that can be incorporated into a BIM 3D model. The combination of BIM modeling and the underlying specifications boosts the quality of the project and its key to success, says Marc Ameryckx. Even after the building is complete, the BIM model is still valuable, providing a repository of “as-built” information that can be used by building managers and security professionals tasked with operating and maintaining the building. For example, if a lock needs to be replaced, retrofitting is simpler because all the information about the lock and existing installation is available in a centralised data file. Revit and ArchiCAD A widely used BIM software is Revit from Autodesk, a program that brings architecture, engineering, and construction disciplines into a unified modeling environment to drive more efficient and cost-effective projects. Another BIM software program is ArchiCAD, developed by the Hungarian company Graphisoft. Openings Studio™ added a plugin for ArchiCAD this year, in addition to Revit. Tailor-made information security solutions We provide tailor-made information security solutions with various hardware on projects with more doors" “We can provide tailor-made information security solutions with various hardware on projects with more doors, adding more flexibility,” says Marc Ameryckx. “Customers do not need to be the experts on the products because we provide expertise as part of our specifications.” For example, how often do building mistakes occur because of a misunderstanding about the electrical needs of a lock and the wrong cabling is installed? The problem is especially expensive if it is discovered only after the walls are complete. Providing complete data about the electrical lock as part of a BIM system avoids the snafu. Another example is the specification of a deadbolt lock on a door that operates with an electric strike. The deadbolt undermines the intended operation of the electric strike and can interfere with escape routes in case of an emergency. The mistake becomes obvious in the BIM environment and can be rectified before consequences impact the real world. Data addition to Opening Suites site ASSA ABLOY Opening Solutions is continuously expanding the data it provides at the Opening Suites site, covering additional functionality and more components including the door, cabling, and electrical connections. Hardware sets are linked to specific doors in the BIM models, including all the details of various components, including article numbers, technical sheets, electrical requirements, all depending on customer expectations. Physical equipment includes QR codes that can be scanned by a smartphone to provide information on the door (A mobile app is in development). More details and more data Experienced BIM consultants work with the Openings Studio software on projects ranging from single doors to large buildings with many doors. Data will be more and more important, and there will be more data inside BIM models Adding more data and detail to the BIM process at the level of each door expands the usefulness of BIM, which has historically been focused on broader issues such as structural work and HVAC. “Openings Studio™ provides all the data to integrate doors and security in the BIM process,” says Marc Ameryckx. The higher level of detail may be a new aspect even for customers who already use BIM software. “Data will be more and more important, and there will be more data inside BIM models,” says Marc Ameryckx. In the future, the use of “digital twins” could expand the capabilities even further; for example, the software could simulate escape routes in case of fire. More data makes more things possible.

Panasonic AI-driven cameras empower an expanding vision of new uses
Panasonic AI-driven cameras empower an expanding vision of new uses

Imagine a world where video cameras are not just watching and reporting for security, but have an even wider positive impact on our lives. Imagine that cameras control street and building lights, as people come and go, that traffic jams are predicted and vehicles are automatically rerouted, and more tills are opened, just before a queue starts to form. Cameras with AI capabilities Cameras in stores can show us how we might look in the latest outfit as we browse. That’s the vision from Panasonic about current and future uses for their cameras that provide artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities at the edge. Panasonic feels that these types of intelligent camera applications are also the basis for automation and introduction of Industry 4.0, in which processes are automated, monitored and controlled by AI-driven systems. 4K network security cameras The company’s i-PRO AI-capable camera line can install and run up to three AI-driven video analytic applications Panasonic’s 4K network security cameras have built-in AI capabilities suitable for this next generation of intelligent applications in business and society. The company’s i-PRO AI-capable camera line can install and run up to three AI-driven video analytic applications. The AI engine is directly embedded into the camera, thus reducing costs and Panasonic’s image quality ensures the accuracy of the analytics outcome. FacePRO facial recognition technology Panasonic began advancing AI technology on the server side with FacePRO, the in-house facial recognition application, which uses AI deep learning capabilities. Moving ahead, they transitioned their knowledge of AI from the server side to the edge, introducing i-PRO security cameras with built-in AI capabilities last summer, alongside their own in-house analytics. Moreover, in line with the Panasonic approach to focus more on collaboration with specialist AI software developers, a partnership with Italian software company, A.I. Tech followed in September, with a range of intelligent applications, partially based on deep learning. Additional collaborations are already in place with more than 10 other developers, across the European Union, working on more future applications. i-PRO AI-capable security cameras Open systems are an important part of Panasonic’s current approach. The company’s i-PRO AI-capable cameras are an open platform and designed for third-party application development, therefore, applications can be built or tailored to the needs of an individual customer. Panasonic use to be a company that developed everything in-house, including all the analytics and applications. “However, now we have turned around our strategy by making our i-PRO security cameras open to integrate applications and analytics from third-party companies,” says Gerard Figols, Head of Security Solutions at Panasonic Business Europe. Flexible and adapting to specific customer needs This new approach allows the company to be more flexible and adaptable to customers’ needs. “At the same time, we can be quicker and much more tailored to the market trend,” said Gerard Figols. He adds, “For example, in the retail space, enabling retailers to enhance the customer experience, in smart cities for traffic monitoring and smart parking, and by event organisers and transport hubs to monitor and ensure safety.” Edge-based analytics offer multiple benefits over server-based systems Edge-based analytics Edge-based analytics offer multiple benefits over server-based systems. On one hand, there are monetary benefits - a cost reduction results from the decreased amount of more powerful hardware required on the server side to process the data, on top of reduction in the infrastructure costs, as not all the full video stream needs to be sent for analysis, we can work solely with the metadata. On the other hand, there are also advantages of flexibility, as well as reliability. Each camera can have its own individual analytic setup and in case of any issue on the communication or server side, the camera can keep running the analysis at the edge, thereby making sure the CCTV system is still fully operational. Most importantly, systems can keep the same high level of accuracy. Explosion of AI camera applications We can compare the explosion of AI camera applications to the way we experienced it for smartphone applications" “We can compare the explosion of AI camera applications to the way we experienced it for smartphone applications,” said Gerard Figols, adding “However, it doesn’t mean the hardware is not important anymore, as I believe it’s more important than ever. Working with poor picture quality or if the hardware is not reliable, and works 24/7, software cannot run or deliver the outcome it has been designed for.” As hardware specialists, Figols believes that Panasonic seeks to focus on what they do best - Building long-lasting, open network cameras, which are capable of capturing the highest quality images that are required for the latest AI applications, while software developers can concentrate on bringing specialist applications to the market. Same as for smartphones, AI applications will proliferate based on market demand and succeed or fail, based on the value that they deliver. Facial recognition, privacy protection and cross line technologies Panasonic has been in the forefront in developing essential AI applications for CCTV, such as facial recognition, privacy protection and cross line. However, with the market developing so rapidly and the potential applications of AI-driven camera systems being so varied and widespread, Panasonic quickly realised that the future of their network cameras was going to be in open systems, which allow specialist developers and their customers to use their sector expertise to develop their own applications for specific vertical market applications, while using i-PRO hardware. Metadata for detection and recognition Regarding privacy, consider that the use of AI in cameras is about generating metadata for the detection and recognition of patterns, rather than identifying individual identities. “However, there are legitimate privacy concerns, but I firmly believe that attitudes will change quickly when people see the incredible benefits that this technology can deliver,” said Gerard Figols, adding “I hope that we will be able to redefine our view of cameras and AI, not just as insurance, but as life advancing and enhancing.” i-PRO AI Privacy Guard One of the AI applications that Panasonic developed was i-PRO AI Privacy Guard Seeking to understand and appreciate privacy concerns, one of the AI applications that Panasonic developed was i-PRO AI Privacy Guard that generates data without capturing individual identities, following European privacy regulations that are among the strictest in the world. Gerard Fogils said, “The combination of artificial intelligence and the latest generation open camera technology will change the world’s perceptions from Big Brother to Big Benefits. New applications will emerge as the existing generation of cameras is updated to the new open and intelligent next generation devices, and the existing role of the security camera will also continue.” Future scope of AI and cameras He adds, “Not just relying on the security cameras for evidence when things have gone wrong, end users will increasingly be able to use AI and the cameras with much higher accuracy to prevent false alarms and in a proactive way to prevent incidents." Gerard Figols concludes, “That could be monitoring and alerting when health and safety guidelines are being breached or spotting and flagging patterns of suspicious behaviour before incidents occur.”

Key-centric access management system: providing the highest possible levels of security
Key-centric access management system: providing the highest possible levels of security

In daily work and life, various locks have always played the role of protecting asset safety. In different usage scenarios, the most appropriate lock must be selected to maximise benefits. In the past applications, the difficulties encountered by managers are as follows. Unlocking authority is difficult to control, unclear access records, emergency unlocking, and troublesome upgrade and installation. Through the following points, how the key-centric access management system solves such problems. Access management system The key-centric access management system, also known as intelligent passive electronic lock system, which is based on three elements: electronic keys, electronic cylinders and management software, can provide powerful and traceable access control. Each smart key is unique and cannot be copied, and in the event of loss or theft, these keys can be quickly disabled. Each smart key is unique and cannot be copied, and in the event of loss or theft, these keys can be disabledIn the process of using traditional mechanical locks, it is not difficult to find that it is quite complex to realise the access control of unlocking. The difficulty is that the keys can be copied at will, the use records are not clear, and the credibility of employees cannot be guaranteed... etc. For managers, this is a safety issue that cannot be ignored. Mechanical lock system And through the key-centric access management system, we can accurately assign access authority for each user, and set different access authority for locks in different areas. For example, we can set the XX user to have access to the archive room (A) from 10:00 on May 1, 2021 to 17:00 on June 1, 2021, within this time range. Outside this time range, there will be no unlock authority. The flexibility of the traditional mechanical lock system is insufficient. There is no clear record to determine who entered the area. It is usually a simple paper record that records the unlocking records of the employees. The authenticity and validity of the system need to be examined. In the key-centric access management system, when an employee unlocks the lock, the unlock record will be synchronised to the management terminal. Remote authorised unlocking With the key-centric access management system, remote authorised unlocking can be realised Through secondary records, managers can easily track employees and supervise employees' visits to each area. In daily work, there are often emergencies that require temporary visits to certain specific areas. If you encounter a situation where the distance is extremely long, and you don’t have the key to that area, you can imagine how bad this is. The process of fetching the keys back and forth is time-consuming and laborious. With the key-centric access management system, remote authorised unlocking can be realised. You can apply for the unlocking authority through the mobile APP, or you can temporarily issue the unlocking authority for the area on the management terminal, which saves time and effort. When faced with the failure of ordinary mechanical locks to meet management needs, some managers can already think of upgrading their management system, that is, the intelligent access control system. Passive electronic locks But before making this decision, the manager will inevitably consider the various costs brought about by the upgrade, including installation costs (cable cost), learning costs, and maintenance costs. Since most of the universal intelligent access control systems on the market require wiring and power supply, the cost of transformation and upgrading is quite high for managers who have such a huge amount of engineering. The key-centric access management system is the ‘gospel’ for managers. Since passive electronic locks and ordinary mechanical locks have the same size, they can be directly retrofitted to existing hardware, and they can be replaced step by step simply and easily. At present, the key-centric access management system is being known and applied by more and more managers and enterprises. Application industries include, such as power utilities, water utilities, public security, telecommunication industry, transportation, etc.